Is Carrageenan Bad For You?

It can be worrying when you hear bad things about foods and ingredients that make up a significant part of your diet. Confusion can abound, and in our experience, a lot of wires can get crossed.

This is why we are taking a closer look at the question is Carrageenan bad for you?

Is Carrageenan Bad for You?

This topic has clearly sparked a lot of conversation. And as a consequence, this has pulled various humble seaweed species into the muddy waters of the misguided ‘Carrageenan is bad’ debate without any true merit.

To set the record straight, there is a big difference between a whole seaweed used as a wholefood or ingredient, and what is commonly referred to as carrageenan.

To be clear, we are actually talking about something that is more accurately called poligeenan, previously known as ‘degraded carrageenan’, and not actually carrageenan at all.

Carrageenan Confusion

Before we look at some of the research, keep in mind that carrageenan and poligeenan are not the same thing.

Poligeenan is where the noted health concerns are found according to many experts. This is due to the impacts studied arising from the chemical degradation of carrageenan into poligeenan as a part of the manufacturing process.

Carrageenan is a polysaccharide. A carbohydrate polymer consisting of natural carbohydrates with a mineral composition that includes calcium, sodium, potassium, and magnesium.

As a naturally-occurring carbohydrate polymer found in specific seaweeds, it is extracted and used in a range of processed food products, commonly as a stabilizer.

On the other hand, poligeenan is something very different. Undergoing certain chemical processes during manufacturing, it has been reported as being connected with triggering, and potentially even causing complications such as:

  • Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS) [1]
  • Gastrointestinal inflammation [2]
  • Ulcers, and [3, 4]
  • Leaky gut. [5]

These studies indicate that it has even been suggested that it can be a possible cause of colon cancer. [6]

Despite the research cited, there are other studies which report that there is not reliable data connecting Carrageenan with IBS and allergic reactions. [7]

How could that be?

This is understood as being based on the confusion between carrageenan and poligeenan (degraded carrageenan). Previous studies are understood to have referred to poligeenan as carrageenan, when this was not clearly the case. [8, 11]

There is a very big difference between poligeenan and the various types of seaweed you can buy in your local store, or through us online.

buy-sea-moss-online-advertisement-detox-and-cure
buy-sea-moss-online-advertisement-detox-and-cure

What is Carrageenan?

You may have heard of a product called Carrageenan or Carrageenins. Carrageenan is a byproduct of red seaweed. Until the commercial farming of other more efficient growing species of seaweed, it was largely sourced from Chondrus Crispus. [8]

The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) first approved the use of Carrageenan in food and drugs in 1961. Subsequent amendments to the approval were published in 1995 [9, 10]

The seaweed is refined and made into carrageenan, which is then typically processed into a gel. It is used worldwide for its stabilizing properties, and as a thickening agent.

Carrageenan that is classified as being of food grade has a larger and more stable molecular weight structure when compared to poligeenan.

Food grade carrageenan does not present the same challenges and risks as poligeenan. It is in a stable and non-degraded form, meaning that it does not degrade upon consumption.

What is Poligeenan?

Poligeenan is not permitted to be used as a food ingredient. It has a molecular weight structure that is as much as 50% to 90% smaller than food grade carrageenan.

Through the acid hydrolysis of carrageenan, where it is exposed to temperatures exceeding 80°C, poligeenan is made. It is intended only for use in non-food related processes, which typically is limited to medical imaging.

Carrageenan
Soaked Natural Sea Moss

So, is Carrageenan bad for you?

Over the years findings have suggested that Carrageenan, as a refined product made from specific seaweeds, may cause irritation in the bowel for some people. However, with the more recent revision of a large number of studies, this information has been called in to question. [11]

In the extensive report “Connecting the Dots: Corporate Influence at the USDA’s National Organic Program” the Cornucopia Institute openly criticized manufacturers of food products over their use of Carrageenan in what were supposed to be organic foods. [12]

The first lines of this report spell out the tone of the paper by titling it the Organic Watergate.

It is worth noting that in this White Paper the term “degraded carrageenan” appears multiple times under headings that appear to look at carrageenan. I don’t see how this approach supports clarity considering the all too pervasive #TLDR culture emerging today.

The Cornucopia Institute make some compelling points in this report with the studies referenced in the timeline from page 12 onwards pertaining to an arguable dilution of fact.

Conjecture around the real problem coming from degraded Carrageenan, a low molecular weighted product, and not from undegraded Carrageenan was refuted within this report. The degraded or undegraded state of the Carrageenan was reported to be, more or less, irrelevant when looking at the effects.

This makes for some interesting debate when considering the opinions of other qualified professionals on the other side of the aisle. [10]

This type of practice is not uncommon, particularly when in the company of large organisations. In Australia we have seen the misappropriation of food labeling standards by large retailers to the point that customers had boycotted entire lines in the stores.

It is each and every one of us at the end of the day who makes the decisions for ourselves here. You do have choices. Even if that choice is to not partake for your own reasons.

buy-sea-moss-online-advertisement-detox-and-cure
buy-sea-moss-online-advertisement-detox-and-cure

Carrageenan, displayed on food labeling as an additive under the number ‘407’ or code ‘E407’ is used as a thickening or stabilizing agent. This is not the whole seaweed.

Used in everything from ice cream, to soy milk, to meat, Carrageenan can be purchased by the ton from manufacturers in China through wholesalers.

A highly politicised situation, as a result, has since unfolded. This has left many people wondering if they should avoid seaweeds altogether.

So what do I think? I’m not inclined to agree with the broad sweeping statements that some have about seaweed being carrageenan, and therefore unsafe.

I don’t think there is valid reason to avoid seaweed altogether based on this misunderstanding – after all Carrageenan and seaweed aren’t actually the same thing.

As I suggested earlier, to say that Carrageenan is the same as seaweed is comparable to saying that high fructose syrup is the same as organic corn. It’s a bit like saying that fresh raspberries are the same as raspberry cordial.

Seaweed-for-Food-What-is-Sea-Moss-Good-For
What is Carrageenan? Find this image on Instagram.

Refined Substances vs. Whole Foods

Refining a substance from primary source does not mean that it is likely to be more effective in higher concentrations. The whole food carries the volume of minerals and vitamins wrapped up inside specific structures that enable them to get to where they are needed in the body.

This is Nature’s clever gift. For example, there’s no need for us to extract the essence of an orange down to simply the ascorbic acid.

There are other minerals, vitamins, and sugars that allow the Vitamin C to make it all the way to where it is needed, intact, to be more effective that 1000mg concentrated into a pill. [13]

A woman could certainly be at high risk of her baby being born with various defects if she was to have too much synthetic Vitamin A in supplement form during her pregnancy. [14]

However, consuming foods which are rich in natural sources of Vitamin A are perfectly safe. To consume the volume of wholefoods that are high in Vitamin A in order to have the same effect as a synthetic, high concentration, supplement is nothing short of a super-human ‘Man Versus Food’ effort.

To allow seaweeds as wholefoods to be caught up in the confusion around the Carrageenan discussion in my opining is irrational. Millions of people have benefited from seaweed being a staple in the wholefood form for hundreds of years, and they will continue to do for hundreds more.

I firmly believe that consuming foods that have these nutrients in their natural balance is healthier, and safer than the higher concentrations manufactured outside of nature.

buy-sea-moss-online-advertisement-detox-and-cure
buy-sea-moss-online-advertisement-detox-and-cure

References

  1. “The Role of Carrageenan and Carboxymethylcellulose in the Development of Intestinal Inflammation” – J. V. Martino, J. V. Limbergen, L. E. Cahill, May 2017 [PubMed] [Frontiers in Pediatrics]
  2. “Review of Harmful Gastrointestinal Effects of Carrageenan in Animal Experiments” – J. K. Tobacman, October 2001 [Environmental Health Perspectives]
  3. “Carrageenan-induced ulceration of the large intestine in the guinea pig” – J. Watt, R. Marcus, 1 February 1971 [BMJ]
  4. “Clarifying the confusion between poligeenan, degraded carrageenan, and carrageenan: A review of the chemistry, nomenclature, and in vivo toxicology by the oral route” – J. M. McKim, J. A. Willoughby Sr., W. R. Blakemore, M. L. Weiner, 16 November 2018 [Taylor & Francis]
  5. “Is Carrageenan Safe?” – M. Greger, 31 July 2013 [NutritionFacts.org]
  6. “Carrageenan in Foods: Response” – J. K. Tobacman, April 2002 [ResearchGate]
  7. “The Role of Carrageenan in Inflammatory Bowel Diseases and Allergic Reactions: Where Do We Stand?” – B. Borsani, R. De Santis, V. Perico, F. Penagini, E. Pendezza, D. Dilillo, A. Bosetti, G. V. Zuccotti, E. D’Auria, 11 August 2021 [MDPI]
  8. “Chapter Three – Chondrus crispus – A Present and Historical Model Organism for Red Seaweeds” – J. Collén, M. L. Cornish, J. Craigie, E. Ficko-Blean, C. Hervé, S. A. Krueger-Hadfield, C. Leblanc, G. Michel, P. Potin, T. Tonon, C. Boyen, 2014 [Science Direct]
  9. “CFR – Code of Federal Regulations Title 21 (21CFR172)” – US Food and Drug Administration, 1 October 2021 [FDA]
  10. “Let’s Be Clear On Carrageenan” – C. A. Hutt, 14 May 2013 [Marinalg International]
  11. “Re-evaluation of carrageenan (E 407) and processed Eucheuma seaweed (E 407a) as food additives” – M. Younes, P. Aggett, F. Aguilar, R. Crebelli, M. Filipič, M. J. Frutos, P. Galtier, D. Gott, U. Gundert-Remy, G. G. Kuhnle, C. Lambré, J. Leblanc, I. T. Lillegaard, P. Moldeus, A. Mortensen, A. Oskarsson, I. Stankovic, I. Waalkens-Berendsen, R. A. Woutersen, M. Wright, L. Brimer,.O. Lindtner, P. Mosesso, A. Christodoulidou, S. Ioannidou, F. Lodi, B. Dusemund, 26 April 2018 [EFSA]
  12. “The Organic Watergate – White Paper Connecting the Dots: Corporate Influence at the USDA’s National Organic Program” – The Cornucopia Institute, 15 May 2012 [Cornucopia White Paper] [Cornucopia.org]
  13. “Synthetic or Food-Derived Vitamin C – Are They Equally Bioavailable?” – A. C. Carr, M. C. M. Vissers, 28 October 2013 [PubMed]
  14. “Safety and toxicity of vitamin A supplements in pregnancy” – PubChem, 27 March 2005 [Food & Nutrition Bulletin]
www.detoxandcure.com - Matthew Carpenter

About the Author

Matthew has been on an active journey towards living a healthy life from a young age. Influenced by his Grandmother, a practicing Naturopath in the 1940's, his views on living holistically were shaped from a young age. Growing up in different parts of Australia, his connection with the Ocean and a passion for sustainability comes through in everything he does and shares.

6 thoughts on “Is Carrageenan Bad For You?”

  1. After reading this I had a look at the food I have in the house. There’s a lot with E407 in it! Should I get rid of these?

  2. Hey Steve, that’s a great question.

    Getting rid of anything that you feel is not good for you is a good move. I wouldn’t suggest just throwing a whole lot of things out in one big go.

    Try replacing them over a period of time with options that don’t have any nasty chemicals in them. These smaller changes, made over a period of time, are easier to stick to when you consider how much of a shock one big change can be.

    Baby steps are more permanent that way. But, if you feel you can move at a faster speed than that, and keep it up, all the more power to you!

  3. I remember seeing a video where Dr. Sebi was showing people sea Moss and what he held up looked like the picture of Eucheuma Cottonii you have here. He called it Chondrus Crispus though. Are you saying Sebi was wrong?

  4. Hi Tanisha,

    Thank you for your question, this is a very good point.

    First off, we have a deep admiration for what Sebi achieved. However, there have been, and still are some challenges with what sea moss is known as. I am familiar with the video you described and have found a snippet of this to share with others here. You can clearly see Sebi holding up a type of sea moss that is twig-like and not a red flat leaf. This is where the biggest difference comes in.

    dr-seb-the-real-sea-moss-www.detoxandcure.com-what-to-know-before-you-buy-sea-moss
    Different types of seaweed have different nutritional values, and this in itself is a gift to us. As we explore the oceans and learn more about this part of our planet each day, the 35,000+ species of seaweed are being studied with greater attention to detail.

    I have used Eucheuma Cottonii (more correctly known as Kappaphycus Alvarezii), Eucheuma Denticulatum, and Gracilaria consistently for years now and have found that there are some pretty big differences with how they present as they are prepared. Once made into a sea moss gel they tend to be very similar.

    As long as the type of seaweed you are using is working for you, it doesn’t really matter what you call ‘sea moss’ at the end of the day. Just be aware that Gracilaria can be called ‘fake sea moss’ by those who don’t understand this. And Eucheuma Denticulatum will not look as pretty as the others, but it has a lot of nutritional value once it is prepared properly.

  5. Hi, great article. I always thought that all Irish Sea Moss/Sea Moss was Chondrus Crispus… does Eucheuma Cottonii have the same advised benefits in helping clear mucus and bowel/digestive aid? Im looking to try find some local Sea Moss gel and the one I am leaning towards uses Eucheuma Cottonii sea moss… Thanks

  6. Hello Sam,

    Thanks for your question and kind feedback.

    We have used both Gracilaria and E. Cottonii for very similar outcomes. We’ve found they both function nicely as a decongestant, digestive aid, and more.

    Other than those two, C. Crispus and U. Pinnatifida. We are also making S. japonica a part of our day for some very interesting and current reasons. With the situation around COVID-19, this seaweed has more recently been looked upon as a potential solution.

Leave a Comment